Jennifer Lopez and Keith Urban currently fill 2 out of 3 judges slots for the upcoming season of American Idol, and producers have been hard pressed to fill number 3. Names like Kanye West, will.i.am and Diddy were all thrown into the mix, but none of the guys appeared to be interested. The former felt that it would hurt his street cred, while the latter has a totally different reason: the fact his ex would be on the panel with him! According to a source, Diddy “felt it was a ‘her or me’ situation” in his negotiations with the show. For now, Puff denies the claim, but there could be some truth to it! I wouldn’t want to sit on a panel every night with my ex either!